Baked Goods

When you walk into Butcher's, the enticing aroma and site of fresh-baked pies, cookies, cakes, sticky buns, pull-aparts, whoopie pies and many other sweet temptations will greet you at the door. We use the highest quality ingredients in our bakery and make everything from scratch to capture that special flavor as if your Grandma baked it herself.

Our bakery selection varies daily. If you are looking for something special, we invite you to call ahead 717-567-3539 and reserve that special treat or stop by to check out our current selection. Many items can be baked with sugar substitute upon request.

Pies

We bake fresh, quality pies in our bakery and right before your eyes! All of our delicious pies are available in 9-inch and 5-inch sizes. Our most popular pies include fresh apple, cherry, lemon sponge, shoofly, peach, pecan, coconut cream, and raspberry.

  • Apple Pie

  • Banana Cream Pie

  • Blueberry Pie

  • Blueberry Custard

  • Blueberry Nut Crumb

  • Boston Cream Pie

  • Chocolate Meringue

  • Cherry Pie

  • Coconut Cream Pie

  • Coconut Custard Pie

  • Egg Custard

  • French Apple Pie

  • Lemon Meringue Pie

  • Lemon Sponge

  • Peanut Butter Pie

  • Pecan Pie

  • Peach Pie

  • Peach Custard

  • Pumpkin Pie

  • Pumpkin Custard

  • Raisin Pie

  • Shoofly Pie

 Cakes

Try one of our moist, fresh-baked cakes for a special occasion or just because. If you have never tried our chocolate cake, BOY!! are you missing something! Feeling more adventurous or in the mood for something else? Try one of our various other flavors.

  • Angel Food

  • Banana

  • Carrot

  • Chocolate w/ Peanut Butter Icing

  • Chocolate w/ Butter Cream Icing

  • Chocolate Cupcakes

  • Coconut Cake

  • Old Fashion Shortcake

  • Sweet Shortcake

  • Walnut Cake

  • White Cake

Cookies

Does anything compare to the aroma of fresh-baked cookies? How about that melt-in-your-mouth deliciousness? From chocolate chip to snickerdoodle to oatmeal raisin, one bite of one of our cookies and you'll fall in love! Cookies are available in small quantities or as trays for special occasions.
Call 717-567-3539 ahead to order.

  • Butterscotch Coconut

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Triple Chocolate

  • Espresso Chocolate Chip

  • Cranberry Vanilla Chip

  • Lemon Blossoms

  • Molasses

  • No Bake

  • Salted Caramel Pretzel

  • Oatmeal Raisin

  • Peanut Butter

  • Peanut Butter Blossoms

  • Raisin-Filled Cookies

  • Sandtart Cookies

  • Snickerdoodle

  • Sugar Cookies

 Muffins

  • Corn

  • Banana Nut

  • Blueberry

  • Shoofly

 Breads

  • Cheese Bread

  • Fruit Breads*
    ie: Strawberry, Peach, Apricot

  • White Bread

  • Wheat Bread

  • Zucchini Bread

  • Pumpernickel Bread

 Breakfast Items

  • Coffee Cakes

  • Cinnamon Pull-a-Parts

 Other Favorites

  • Apple Dumplins

  • Brownies

  • Cheddar Cheese Biscuits

  • Dinner Rolls

  • Egg Custard Cups

  • Peanut Butter Fudge

  • Whoopie Pies
    Chocolate, Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Pumpkin, Sugar, Oatmeal